Which Mold Protocol to Follow: Shoemaker, Nathan, Crista, or Campbell?

You finally find doctors who take mold illness seriously. Then you discover that they disagree about how to test for it, which treatments to use, and whether you have to be out of mold to start healing.

Now you’re left comparing mold treatment protocols while exhausted, foggy, and worried about spending more money on something that may not work or that your body might not tolerate.

One person says binders changed her life. Another says she couldn’t improve until she took anti-fungals. Someone else insists you need to follow a specific sequence or you’ll never recover.

It can start to feel as though choosing the wrong approach could cost you your chance to get well.

You should not have to become an expert in four different treatment models to receive thoughtful care.

My approach is to understand what each model offers, recognize its limitations, and build a comprehensive treatment plan around the person sitting in front of me.

As a naturopathic physician with more than a decade of experience treating patients with mold illness, advanced training in multiple mold treatment approaches, and personal experience recovering from mold illness, I’ve learned a thing or two about what works. My approach doesn’t follow a strict protocol, and I’ll explain why as we learn about the four main mold treatment approaches.

Comparing the four mold treatment approaches

Each of these is an approach to treating mycotoxin-related illness.

Each of them was developed by a different brilliant clinician and researcher in the specialty of mold-related illness.

Some of them are taught as “strict protocols”, including the Shoemaker and Campbell protocols. Neil Nathan and Dr. Crista’s approaches are more frameworks for how to test and treat.

While they have the same goal, they’re actually quite different.

The Shoemaker protocol: a structured CIRS model

Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker’s work centers on CIRS, a chronic inflammatory illness associated with biotoxin exposure, which could be exposure to water-damaged buildings (or other biotoxins).  You can be sick from mold without this chronic inflammatory pattern.

Testing involves looking at a variety of inflammatory markers in the blood.  Unfortunately, if these markers are high, it doesn’t identify the REASON they’re high (the cause).  It’s just identifying a particular pattern of inflammation in the body.   This testing can also miss people who are sick from mold, but not stuck in this chronic inflammatory response.  This is different from mycotoxin antibody or urine testing which is testing for the cause.

After the Shoemaker inflammatory marker panel comes back positive, Dr. Shoemaker directs you to go in search of a cause for this chronic inflammatory pattern, usually by testing for mold, endotoxins, and actinobacteria.

His treatment model begins with addressing exposure to mold, endotoxins, and actinobacteria, followed by prescription binding agents such as cholestyramine, then additional steps based on the specific inflammatory and hormonal markers found to be abnormal. Its defining characteristic is the prescribed sequence of treatments.

One useful distinction between this protocol and all three others, is that Dr. Shoemaker’s protocol does not address fungal colonization (when fungus is growing in the sinuses, lungs, or digestive tract).  Dr. Shoemaker, unlike the other experts in the mold world, believes that MARCoNS, or antibiotic-resistant staphylococcus bacteria is the most important overgrowth or infection to address in mold patients.  

I disagree with Dr. Shoemaker on this.  I have found treatment of fungal colonization to be critical for recovery.  

The last big distinction is that the other protocols include important pieces of recovery, such as limbic system retraining, mast cell stabilization, tissue protection, and repair of damaged tissues.‍ ‍I find all of these important in most patients that get really sick from toxic mold.

One thing I hear often from patients who have tried the strict version of the Shoemaker protocol is that they didn’t tolerate treatment, and there was no flexibility from the practitioner to pivot and use a different approach.

This is why I think it’s best to choose a mold-literate practitioner who has training in multiple approaches and doesn’t force you to use an approach that isn’t working for your body.

Neil Nathan: treatment tolerance matters

Dr. Neil Nathan began his training in mold illness with Dr. Shoemaker. 

Then, once he really started treating lots of toxic mold patients, he found that the Shoemaker protocol didn’t work for quite a few people and left some important elements out of treatment that were needed to really get the patient well.

Over time, he figured out what was missing, even for the most sensitive patients who struggled to tolerate treatment at all.

Dr. Nathan found that calming mast cells, regulating the limbic system and vagus nerve, anti-fungal treatment for colonization, and treatment of some other chronic infections were very important to recovery in the right patient.  He also found that natural binders often worked very well, and cholestyramine and welchol were not always helpful or necessary.  

He’s a big fan of urine mycotoxin testing instead of CIRS testing because urine mycotoxin testing looks for the cause, not the effect.  

That being said, he also acknowledges it has significant issues and limitations. It was just the best test available when he learned to treat mold illness, and he still uses it because it’s what he’s most familiar with.  

Here are the main limitations of urine mycotoxin testing:

  • Eating moldy foods impacts the results - they can make mycotoxin levels in the urine high, obscuring whether there has been an environmental toxic mold exposure.

    • This can be offset by eating a low mold diet for 3 days before the test.

  • The sickest people with the poorest detoxification often end up with normal test results.  It’s estimated that this happens in 10-15% of patients, and the diagnosis is missed if the doctor does not perform a different type of test.

  • Because labs that test urine mycotoxins use different methods of measuring what’s in the urine, it’s common for different toxins to be found in the urine depending on which lab was used for the test.

  • High urine mycotoxin levels cannot tell you whether you’re currently being exposed to toxic mold, have mold colonized in your body, or just high levels from past toxic exposure.

Something that Dr. Neil Nathan and Dr. Jill Crista developed together was an approach to mycotoxin detoxification that varies based on which toxins are present in the person’s body.  It makes complete sense to approach treatment this way, because different mycotoxins get detoxified in different ways, and different binders help get certain toxins out more effectively.  I have found this incredibly helpful and more efficient to individualize detox support to what the patient was actually exposed to.  

One of the biggest distinctions of what he teaches is how to approach the highly sensitive patient that tends to react poorly to foods, medications, and supplements.  He has figured out how to calm a sensitive system so treatment can be tolerated, and always starts with exceedingly low doses of treatments to make sure they are tolerated. 

While this is ideal for a highly sensitive patient, Neil Nathan’s approach can be much slower than necessary for someone who tolerates treatment well.

That’s why it’s so important that the protocol be tailored to your tolerance level.  A protocol tailored to your unique tolerance is what will get you to recovery the fastest. 

Many patients think that faster and harder is always the way to go with treatment; that pushing through even if they’re having severe side effects will get them to the finish line faster.  That couldn’t be further from the truth.  Pushing the body this hard will just cause more stress than the system can handle and set you back.

A plan that looks reasonable on paper still needs to work in your actual body.

I have learned Dr. Neil Nathan’s approach, and find it invaluable with many patients. 

That being said, urine mycotoxin testing is not my preferred test for mycotoxin illness at this time due to the issues noted above. 

Jill Crista: foundations, protection, and repair

Dr. Jill Crista is a brilliant expert in mold illness.  She has read more research on mycotoxins than probably anyone else on the planet. 

Early on, her approach was very similar to Dr. Nathan’s and indeed they co-taught a physician mentorship for several years.  Dr. Jill’s approach has always included more natural therapies due to her naturopathic training. 

However, just like Dr. Nathan, she fully supports use of pharmaceuticals where appropriate in the healing journey from mold.

She uses both urine mycotoxin testing and mycotoxin antibody testing, noting that neither test is perfect, and they’re better done together.

Over time, her approach has evolved to emphasize supporting the detox pathways involved in mycotoxin excretion, protecting cells, and using gentler binders rather than relying on strong binders. These gentler binders can be taken with food and other supplements over longer periods without causing nutrient deficiencies.

She also continues to pioneer precision mycotoxin detox that focuses on how to specifically target each type of mycotoxin, to get them out of the body faster.

Getting out of the toxic environment, diet change, detox support, gentle binders, mast cell stabilization, treatment of fungal colonization, cellular repair, microbiome recovery, and the blending of both natural and pharmaceutical treatment where warranted, are all part of her approach.

I have trained with Dr. Crista, and her approach has very much influenced how I treat mold illness.  

In very recent history, she has developed a supplement line for patients suffering from mold illness and protocols of treatment with those supplements for each of the major mycotoxins.  I find some of these products to be incredibly helpful for treatment, and in other cases, I use other options. 

For people who cannot afford mold-literate medical care, I think Dr. Crista’s free information about mycotoxin detox and her products can be a good place to start.   They do not cover all elements of treatment or guidance on how to tailor that treatment to your body.

Andrew Campbell: mycotoxin antibodies and antifungal treatment

Dr. Andrew Campbell has a strict protocol, that is primarily focused on treatment of fungal colonization after toxic mold exposure with a few supportive supplements. 

He advocates for using mycotoxin antibody testing instead of urine mycotoxin testing or CIRS testing for several reasons.

  • Food and supplements don’t affect the results, therefore no test prep diet is needed

  • Poor detoxifiers will not get false negative results with this test.

  • IgE antibodies are short-lived, so can be used to assess if there’s been recent significant exposure to these mycotoxins.

  • IgG antibodies are long-lived and seem to correlate with body burden and/or fungal colonization of the body

I would agree that I find this test to generally be the most helpful for these reasons.  It does have its own limitations.  These limitations include:

  • It requires a blood draw by a local phlebotomist or lab that does specialty blood draws. You cannot get the blood drawn for it at Quest or Labcorp or a local hospital.

  • If someone had a significant deficit in IgG or IgE antibody production, it might affect these results.  I have not seen this yet. 

  • Just like urine mycotoxin testing, it has not been validated by the FDA.

Beyond testing, Dr. Andrew Campbell emphasizes the treatment of fungal colonization as the essential element to mold recovery. 

For this purpose, he uses only itraconazole for digestive and systemic treatment, and amphotericin B nasal spray for sinus colonization.

He does not significantly support detoxification and does not use any binders.

While itraconazole and amphotericin B sinus treatment can both be pivotal tools in mold recovery for the right person, and I use them a lot, they’re not enough on their own in many cases and not the right fit for everyone.   

Beyond that, I actually DO find binders and other detoxification pathway support incredibly helpful for many patients, and both can really help patients tolerate anti-fungal treatment as well as recover faster.

The research does not give us a simple winner

Mold and mycotoxin related health effects are real. For a review of the research, checkout my blog article, Is Mold Toxicity Real?

That being said, research into the optimal approach to treatment has not been sufficiently studied.   There has been no head-to-head trial comparing these main treatment protocols or approaches. 

What we have is clinical evidence.  And the clinical evidence in my practice is clear. 

  1. There’s no perfect test, but the mycotoxin antibody test seems to provide the fewest false negatives, has the fewest interfering factors, and provides more information than urine mycotoxin or CIRS testing.

  2. There’s no perfect protocol that works for every patient.  This is true in every field of medicine.  Each approach has elements of it that are helpful and appropriate to use in the right patient. 

  3. If a protocol or approach isn’t working for a patient, “pushing through” won’t make things better. 

  4. Every toxic exposure is different, and treatment tailored to which toxins are present produces better results in my experience.

  5. Mold isn’t always the only driver of illness. It can co-exist with other things that can make you sick like other toxins, nutrient deficiencies, nervous system dysregulation, and infections. Addressing all the drivers can be necessary for the system to regain health and balance.

In my experience of treating complex chronic illness for over a decade, and my own recovery from toxic mold, the best outcomes generally require attention to five pillars: Avoidance, Foundations, Protect, Fight, and Repair.

How we address those pillars and how much support you need in each varies considerably.

One person may need substantial help with inflammation and treatment tolerance before we introduce more active interventions. Another is tolerate detox support well, but may need more attention to persistent fungal colonization. Someone else may be receiving appropriate physical treatment while still living with intense fear, hypervigilance, and nervous system reactivity.

Understanding the differences between mold treatment protocols can help you make a more informed choice. The goal is to find care that can recognize those differences in you…

And make a treatment plan that works FOR YOU.

My approach: five pillars, personalized to your body

I do not follow a strict protocol. I draw from multiple clinicians’ work and use particular tools when there is a reason to use them.

Individualized care requires more than assembling pieces from several protocols.

Every recommendation should answer a practical question: What are we trying to change, why is this appropriate now, and how will we know whether it helps?

In my experience, all five pillars generally need attention for the best outcome. That does not mean everyone needs the same prescriptions, supplements, tests, or timeline.

Each pillar gives us an area to assess. Your situation determines what we do about it.

1. Avoidance: address what you’re being exposed to

We look at your exposure history and the practical steps needed to investigate and address ongoing toxic mold exposure.

This includes helping you navigate the decisions that can make recovery feel overwhelming: evaluating your environment, finding appropriate professional support, and understanding what needs attention.

All of my mold illness patients are provided with an in-depth course on how to heal your environment from mold (or successfully remove yourself from it).

If you can’t resolve the toxic exposure right away, you can still support your body.  We work on protecting your body and supporting detoxification and fungal burden while developing a realistic plan to reduce exposure.

2. Foundations: give your body the conditions it needs to recover

Sleep, nourishment, hydration, bowel function, appropriate movement, nervous system regulation, and avoiding other toxins deserve attention from the beginning.

These can sound basic when you’re dealing with a complicated, toxic illness. Yet someone who is barely sleeping, not getting enough key nutrients, and severely constipated isn’t going to get good results and may even be unable to tolerate more targeted treatment for mycotoxin illness.

Nervous system care belongs here, too. The fear, trauma, and constant vigilance surrounding mold illness can become a substantial part of what needs treatment.

3. Protect: support the systems under strain

This pillar includes addressing inflammation, cellular protection, extra nutritional support, and the body’s ability to detoxify the cells and the whole system.

4. Fight: pathogen overgrowth, fungal colonization, and chronic infections

Many patients need evaluation and treatment for fungal overgrowth or colonization.  Mold can setup shop in the body and produce an internal toxin factory there. 

Candida and other fungi often get out of control in a mold-sick body.

Chronic viral infections, tick-borne infections, and others can run rampant in the immunosuppressive environment of toxic mold.

We can help your immune system regain control and eliminate invaders.  This is an important step to get the whole system back into balance.

5. Repair: help affected systems recover

Removing an exposure, detoxifying, and treating the fungal burden in the body aren’t always enough to get the body back into optimal health.  That’s because mycotoxins can damage cells, tissues, and the microbiome, making support for repair necessary.

So pillar 5 is to assess what remains: digestive issues, mitochondrial dysfunction, disrupted sleep, nutritional deficiencies, cognitive impairments, nervous system reactivity, or other identified concerns.

The aim is not just to get the toxins and fungus out!  It’s to help you return to the activities and relationships you enjoy - working, having hobbies, seeing your friends, enjoying meals, making plans, and having enough capacity to participate in your life.

These pillars give treatment direction while leaving room for your individual needs.

We revisit them as you improve, encounter obstacles, or develop new information. That ongoing judgment is a central part of the care I provide.

Choosing a practitioner who can explain the plan

You do not need to settle every disagreement between mold clinicians before seeking help.

A useful consultation should leave you clearer about the approach to your care.

Questions worth asking include:

  • How do you diagnose mold illness and why?

  • Do you follow a protocol for treatment or adapt treatment to the patient?

  • What will we do if I feel worse?

  • How do you help guide the testing and healing process of my environment?

Listen for an explanation that makes sense to you and allows room for flexibility.

A practitioner can have a clear approach while remaining willing to change course, and adapt to your body.

A recovery plan you can stop trying to assemble alone

By the time many people contact me, they have become the researcher, care coordinator, and interpreter of every conflicting opinion.

They are doing all of that while sick.

My role is to help make the picture clearer: what needs further investigation, which concerns deserve priority, and how to address the physical illness alongside the nervous system patterns that have developed around it.

I provide medical telehealth care for patients in Oregon and Colorado.

When you’re ready for a treatment plan that accounts for your symptoms, sensitivities, and the life you want to return to, book a free chronic illness clarity call.

We can discuss your situation and whether my approach is a good fit.

Dr. Karen Cureton

About Dr. Karen Cureton, ND, LAc
Dr. Karen Cureton is a licensed naturopathic physician and acupuncturist specializing in mold illness, complex chronic illness, and nervous system dysregulation. Drawing on more than a decade of clinical experience and her own recovery from mold illness, she integrates personalized naturopathic care with trauma-informed nervous system healing.

https://drkarencureton.com/about-me
Next
Next

 Mold-Literate Naturopath vs. Conventional Doctor: Why Your Regular Doctor Keeps Missing This